Posted by Doug on March 12, 2008
This is purely hypothetical, because no team would ever be faced with this choice, but I think it's a fun thought experiment and I'd be interested to hear your thoughts on it.
I'll offer a single question, then I'll give it a couple of twists.
The question: If you were the Miami Dolphins, would you trade the first overall pick for the entire fifth round (all 32 picks)?
For me, two things instantly pop into my mind. First, I wonder about the salary cap impact. Second, I'd be concerned about my ability to evaluate 32 marginal talents during the short duration of a single training camp. So here are a couple of follow-ups.
1. If it were mandated from above that the trade would be salary-cap neutral for the first two years, would you trade #1 for the fifth round?
2. If you got a special practice-squad exemption that allowed you to carry all your fifth-rounders for a full year to evaluate them, would you trade #1 for the fifth round?
Tomorrow, I'll look at the historical data to see how many starters and how many stars generally emerge from the fifth round. For now I'm interested in your gut reactions.