NFL EloRater AboutHide About

This is a community-based project with the goal of rating the best players in NFL history. In the matchup below, choose the player who you believe was the better player. It is up to you to determine how much weight to give to offense versus defense, peak value versus career value, regular season versus playoffs, etc.

Current Top Ten:
1. Jerry Rice (1986)
2. Walter Payton (1969)
3. Johnny Unitas (1963)
4. Jim Brown (1953)
5. Steve Young (1951)
6. Merlin Olsen (1948)
7. Joe Greene (1947)
8. John Hannah (1940)
9. Ray Nitschke (1939)
10. Deacon Jones (1939)

» Read the fine details or view the complete ratings.

Login or Create an Account to Save your Ratings · Note: We will be adding the ability to make personal ratings soon

Who's Better: or ? Skip

Share your vote:
  Tale of the Tape
  Caroline McCaffrey
HoF No No
Pos DB-HB WR
Height 6-0 6-5
Weight 185 215
Yrs 1956-1965 1991-2003
Years 9 12
Career AV 27 80
Games 118 185
Games Started 0 109
Pro Bowls 1 1
MVP Awards 0 0
All-Pro Teams 1 1
First Team All-Pro 0 0
College Illinois Stanford
Teams Bears
Giants
49ers
Broncos
Seasonal AV
(Best → Worst)
Rk Caroline McCaffrey
1 7.0 14.0
2 6.0 13.0
3 6.0 9.0
4 4.0 9.0
5 2.0 7.0
6 2.0 7.0
7 6.0
8 5.0
9 3.0
10 2.0
11 2.0
12 2.0
13 1.0
Total 27.0 80.0
Wt Sum** 24.6 65.6
J.C. Caroline
  Career Stats
Rushing TD2
Receiving TD1
Fumble Return TD1
Intercept. Ret. TD2
Touchdowns6
Points Scored36
Interceptions24
Intercept. Ret. Yds405
Long Intercep. Return79
Fumbles4
Fumbles Recovered6
Fumble Return Yds57
Ed McCaffrey
  Career Stats
Receiving TD55
Touchdowns55
2-pt. Conv. Made3
Points Scored336
Receptions565
Receiving Yds7,422
Yds/Reception13.1
Long Reception78
Receptions/Game3.1
Receiving Yds/Game40.1
Fumbles5