Support us without the ads? Go Ad-Free.

NFL EloRater

This is a community-based project with the goal of rating the best players in NFL history. Please read the fine details or view the complete ratings below.

» Please note that this launched on August 22nd and all players began with a rating of 1500.


All-Time Top 10:
1. Walter Payton (1974)
2. Jim Brown (1961)
3. Barry Sanders (1960)
4. Otto Graham (1912)
5. Emlen Tunnell (1903)
6. Johnny Unitas (1876)
7. Y.A. Tittle (1873)
8. Bruce Matthews (1873)
9. Merlin Olsen (1871)
10. Derrick Brooks (1871)


Active Top 10:
1. Drew Brees (1822)
2. Charles Woodson (1750)
3. James Harrison (1747)
4. Troy Polamalu (1746)
5. Tom Brady (1728)
6. Peyton Manning (1726)
7. Steve Smith (1704)
8. Ben Roethlisberger (1674)
9. Jared Allen (1664)
10. Jason Witten (1652)

» Would You Like To Participate?

Top 721 on Offense

Top 814 on Defense