| Offensive Starters | | | | | |
|---|
| QB | Johnny Unitas*+ | 31 | 8 | 14 | 158 for 305, 2,824 yards, 19 td, 6 int, & 37 rushes for 162 yards and 2 td | Pittsburgh Steelers / 9th / 102nd pick / 1955 |
|---|
| HB | Lenny Moore*+ | 31 | 8 | | 157 rushes for 584 yards, 16 td, & 21 catches for 472 yards and 3 td | Baltimore Colts / 1st / 9th pick / 1956 |
|---|
| FB | Jerry Hill | 25 | 3 | | 88 rushes for 384 yards, 5 td, & 14 catches for 113 yards and 1 td | Denver Broncos / 2nd / 9th pick / 1961, Baltimore Colts / 3rd / 35th pick / 1961 |
|---|
| FL | Jimmy Orr | 29 | 6 | | 40 catches for 867 yards, 6 td | Los Angeles Rams / 25th / 291st pick / 1957 |
|---|
| SE | Raymond Berry* | 31 | 9 | | 43 catches for 663 yards, 6 td | Baltimore Colts / 20th / 232nd pick / 1954 |
|---|
| TE | John Mackey | 23 | 1 | | 22 catches for 406 yards, 2 td, & 1 rush for -1 yards and 0 td | Baltimore Colts / 2nd / 19th pick / 1963, New York Jets / 5th / 35th pick / 1963 |
|---|
| LT | Bob Vogel* | 23 | 1 | 14 | | Baltimore Colts / 1st / 5th pick / 1963, Boston Patriots / 3rd / 23rd pick / 1963 |
|---|
| LG | Jim Parker*+ | 30 | 7 | | 3 fumbles recovered | Baltimore Colts / 1st / 8th pick / 1957 |
|---|
| C | Dick Szymanski* | 32 | 9 | 0 | | Baltimore Colts / 2nd / 16th pick / 1955 |
|---|
| RG | Alex Sandusky | 32 | 10 | | 1 fumble recovered | Baltimore Colts / 16th / 184th pick / 1954 |
|---|
| RT | George Preas | 31 | 9 | 0 | | Baltimore Colts / 5th / 51st pick / 1955 |
|---|
| Defensive Starters | | | | | |
|---|
| LDE | Gino Marchetti*+ | 37 | 12 | | 0 interceptions, 2 fumbles recovered | Dallas Texans / 2nd / 14th pick / 1952 |
|---|
| LDT | Fred Miller | 24 | 1 | | 0 interceptions, 1 fumble recovered | Baltimore Colts / 7th / 93rd pick / 1962, Oakland Raiders / 26th / 201st pick / 1962 |
|---|
| RDT | Billy Ray Smith | 29 | 7 | | 0 interceptions, 3 fumbles recovered | Los Angeles Rams / 3rd / 26th pick / 1957 |
|---|
| RDE | Ordell Braase | 32 | 7 | 0 | | Baltimore Colts / 14th / 160th pick / 1954 |
|---|
| LLB | Steve Stonebreaker | 26 | 2 | 13 | 0 interceptions, 3 fumbles recovered | Denver Broncos / 34th / 266th pick / 1962, Minnesota Vikings / 12th / 155th pick / 1961 |
|---|
| MLB | Bill Pellington | 37 | 11 | | 2 interceptions, 1 fumble recovered | |
|---|
| RLB | Don Shinnick | 29 | 7 | | 3 interceptions, 0 fumbles recovered | Baltimore Colts / 2nd / 20th pick / 1957 |
|---|
| LCB | Bobby Boyd*+ | 27 | 4 | | 9 interceptions, 1 fumble recovered | Baltimore Colts / 10th / 119th pick / 1960 |
|---|
| RCB | Lenny Lyles | 28 | 6 | | 2 interceptions, 1 fumble recovered | Baltimore Colts / 1st / 11th pick / 1958 |
|---|
| LS | Jerry Logan | 23 | 1 | 14 | 6 interceptions, 3 fumbles recovered | Baltimore Colts / 4th / 47th pick / 1963, Oakland Raiders / 9th / 65th pick / 1963 |
|---|
| RS | Jim Welch | 26 | 4 | | 0 interceptions, 1 fumble recovered | Baltimore Colts / 3rd / 34th pick / 1960 |
|---|
| Special Teams Starters | | | | | |
|---|
| K | Lou Michaels | 29 | 6 | | 17 of 35 field goals & 53 of 54 extra points | Los Angeles Rams / 1st / 4th pick / 1958 |
|---|
| P | Joe Don Looney | 22 | Rook | | 32 punts for a 42.4 average, 0 blocked | New York Giants / 1st / 12th pick / 1964, Kansas City Chiefs / 6th / 44th pick / 1964 |
|---|
| PR | Wendell Harris | 24 | 2 | 4 | 17 punt returns for a 12.6 average and 0 td | Baltimore Colts / 1st / 9th pick / 1962, San Diego Chargers / 7th / 51st pick / 1962 |
|---|
| KR | Joe Don Looney | 22 | Rook | | 14 kick returns for a 24.6 average and 0 td | New York Giants / 1st / 12th pick / 1964, Kansas City Chiefs / 6th / 44th pick / 1964 |
|---|
Roster