Explore the game you love with Stathead Football, your all-access pass to the Pro Football Ref database. Sign up today and your first month is on us.

Indianapolis Colts Career Punting Leaders

Team Names: Baltimore Colts, Indianapolis Colts

Seasons: 72 (1953 to 2024)

Record (W-L-T): 558-504-8

Playoff Record: 23-25

Super Bowls Won: 2 (4 Appearances)

Championships Won*: 4

All-time Passing Leader: Peyton Manning 4,682/7,210, 54,828 yds, 399 TD

All-time Rushing Leader: Edgerrin James 2,188 att, 9,226 yds, 64 TD

All-time Receiving Leader: Marvin Harrison 1,102 rec, 14,580 yds, 128 TD

All-time Scoring Leader: Adam Vinatieri 1,515 points

All-time AV Leader: Peyton Manning 219 AV

Winningest Coach: Tony Dungy 85-27-0

Become a Stathead & surf this site ad-free.

Punting

Punting Table
							Punting
Rk	Player	From	To	G	Pos	AV	Pnt	Yds	Y/P	RetYds	Net	NY/P	Lng	TB	TB%	In20	In20%	Blck
1	Rohn Stark	1982	1994	197	P	41	985	43162	43.8	5752	35190	35.5	72	111	11.3%	222	22.5%	7
2	David Lee	1966	1978	184	P	30	838	34019	40.6	3214	20902	24.6	76	54	6.4%	55	6.6%	11
3	Hunter Smith	1999	2008	160	P	24	577	25038	43.4	3335	20483	35.2	69	61	10.6%	193	33.4%	5
4	Pat McAfee	2009	2016	127	P	21	575	26653	46.4	2641	23048	39.8	74	49	8.5%	193	33.6%	4
5	Rigoberto Sanchez	2017	2024	101	P	13	388	17798	45.9	1220	16278	41.7	79	15	3.9%	151	38.9%	2
6	Chris Gardocki	1995	1998	64	P	11	277	12403	44.8	1791	10112	36.5	72	25	9.0%	80	28.9%	0
7	Tom Gilburg	1961	1965	69	P	10	232	9606	41.4	0			66					0
8	Cotton Davidson	1954	1957	24	QB		119	4344	36.5				56					1
9	Bucky Dilts	1979	1979	16	P	0	99	3657	36.9	296	3261	32.3	53	5	5.1%	21	21.2%	2
10	Ray Brown	1958	1960	36	P	2	95	3733	39.3	0			60					0
11	Mike Bragg	1980	1980	16	P	1	82	3203	39.1	357	2726	32.5	59	6	7.3%	22	26.8%	2
12	Mike Garrett	1981	1981	16	P	2	78	3071	39.4	402	2629	33.7	57	2	2.6%	11	14.1%	0
13	Matt Haack	2022	2022	17	P	2	70	3133	44.8	258	2811	39.6	70	3	4.3%	28	40.0%	1
14	George Taliaferro	1953	1954	22	LH		65	2437	37.5				61					0
15	Monte Brethauer	1953	1955	24	DB		55	2161	39.3				56					0
16	Dave Sherer	1959	1959	12	P		51	2132	41.8				60					0
17	Bert Rechichar	1953	1959	79	RS		38	1433	37.7				56					0
18	Joe Don Looney	1964	1964	13	HB	3	32	1358	42.4	0			64					0
19	L.G. Dupre	1955	1959	48	HB		29	1024	35.3				54					0
20	Dick Horn	1958	1958	5	QB		19	617	32.5				48					0
21	Tom Keane	1953	1954	24	DB		18	753	41.8				56					0
22	Blair Kiel	1986	1987	7	QB	2	17	630	37.1	47	563	33.1	50	1	5.9%	3	17.6%	0
23	Ryan Allen	2020	2020	2	P	0	6	276	46.0	36	220	36.7	51	1	16.7%	2	33.3%	0
24	Jeremy Kapinos	2010	2010	1	P	0	4	179	44.8	10	148	37.0	55	1	25.0%	2	50.0%	0
25	Jerry Logan	1963	1972	140	LS	85	4	121	30.3	0			55					0
26	Ed Brown	1965	1965	1	QB	0	2	80	40.0	0			49					0
27	Craig Colquitt	1987	1987	1	P	0	2	61	30.5	7	54	18.0	33	0	0.0%	0	0.0%	1
28	Lamar McHan	1961	1963	18	QB	1	1	22	22.0	0			2					0
29	Avatus Stone	1958	1958	1	HB		1	28	28.0				28					0
Rk	Player	From	To	G	Pos	AV	Pnt	Yds	Y/P	RetYds	Net	NY/P	Lng	TB	TB%	In20	In20%	Blck
30	Mike Vanderjagt	1998	2005	125	K	38	1	29	29.0	0	29	29.0	29	0	0.0%	1	100.0%	0

More Indianapolis Colts Pages

Indianapolis Colts Franchise Page

Career Leaders

Season Leaders

History

People

Other

Indianapolis Colts Career Punting Leaders

Punting

More Indianapolis Colts Pages

Full Site Menu

FAQs, Tip & Tricks