| Rank | Player (age), + - HOFer, Bold - Active | FGM | Years | Teams |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Matt Stover (40) | 448 | 1991-2008 | 2TM |
| 2. | John Carney (44) | 446 | 1988-2008 | 7TM |
| 3. | Jason Elam (38) | 416 | 1993-2008 | 2TM |
| 4. | Jason Hanson (38) | 398 | 1992-2008 | det |
| 5. | John Kasay (39) | 376 | 1991-2008 | 2TM |
| 6. | Adam Vinatieri (36) | 322 | 1996-2008 | 2TM |
| 7. | Ryan Longwell (34) | 286 | 1997-2008 | 2TM |
| 8. | Olindo Mare (35) | 270 | 1997-2008 | 3TM |
| 9. | David Akers (34) | 219 | 1998-2008 | 2TM |
| 10. | Joe Nedney (35) | 217 | 1996-2008 | 7TM |
| 11. | Kris Brown (32) | 216 | 1999-2008 | 2TM |
| 12. | Phil Dawson (33) | 204 | 1999-2008 | cle |
| 13. | Sebastian Janikowski (30) | 197 | 2000-2008 | rai |
| 14. | Jay Feely (32) | 195 | 2001-2008 | 4TM |
| 15. | Rian Lindell (31) | 194 | 2000-2008 | 2TM |
| 16. | Neil Rackers (32) | 182 | 2000-2008 | 2TM |
| 17. | Shayne Graham (31) | 165 | 2001-2008 | 3TM |
| 18. | Martin Gramatica (33) | 155 | 1999-2008 | 4TM |
| 19. | Jeff Reed (29) | 151 | 2002-2008 | pit |
| 20. | Josh Brown (29) | 134 | 2003-2008 | 2TM |
| 21. | Matt Bryant (33) | 130 | 2002-2008 | 4TM |
| 22. | Nate Kaeding (26) | 109 | 2004-2008 | sdg |
| 23. | Josh Scobee (26) | 100 | 2004-2008 | jax |
| Robbie Gould (26) | 100 | 2005-2008 | chi | |
| 25. | Rob Bironas (30) | 98 | 2005-2008 | oti |
| 26. | Lawrence Tynes (30) | 92 | 2004-2008 | 2TM |
| 27. | Mike Nugent (26) | 75 | 2005-2008 | nyj |
| 28. | Stephen Gostkowski (24) | 65 | 2006-2008 | nwe |
| 29. | Shaun Suisham (27) | 60 | 2005-2008 | 2TM |
| 30. | Mason Crosby (24) | 50 | 2007-2008 | gnb |
| 31. | Dave Rayner (26) | 42 | 2005-2008 | 5TM |
| 32. | Nick Folk (24) | 35 | 2007-2008 | dal |
| 33. | Nick Novak (27) | 19 | 2005-2008 | 3TM |
| 34. | Matt Prater (24) | 18 | 2007-2008 | 2TM |
| 35. | Dan Carpenter (23) | 13 | 2008 | mia |
| 36. | Craig Hentrich (37) | 8 | 1994-2008 | 2TM |
| 37. | Garrett Hartley (22) | 5 | 2008 | nor |
| Connor Barth (22) | 5 | 2008 | kan | |
| 39. | Michael Koenen (26) | 4 | 2005-2008 | atl |
| 40. | Taylor Mehlhaff (23) | 3 | 2008 | nor |
| 41. | Wes Welker (27) | 1 | 2004-2008 | 3TM |
| Steven Hauschka (23) | 1 | 2008 | rav |