When an NFL game is granted a rare extra session, the excitement of the contest reaches a new level. The scoreboard: a cruel mirror reflecting the agonizing symmetry of a tie. The gridiron ecstasy is the crucible of NFL overtime, a stage where the fate of a game hinges on a knife’s edge, and the rules, though nuanced, hold the key to victory or defeat.

Whether you’re a seasoned football fanatic or a curious newcomer, navigating the complexities of overtime can be daunting. Fear not, for this post will serve as your compass, guiding you through the labyrinth of regulations and unwritten narratives that govern this most thrilling yet controversial chapter of the NFL.

But overtime isn’t just about Xs and Os; it’s about heart. It’s about witnessing the resilience of a defense that bends but doesn’t break, the heroics of a quarterback leading a last-ditch drive, and the electrifying energy of a stadium on the precipice of pandemonium.

First, let’s dispel the myth that overtime is sudden death. 

While a single score can seal the deal, in most cases, both teams get to strut their stuff on offense. But the dance of possession is far from a simple back-and-forth. The seemingly innocuous coin toss holds the weight of fate, granting one team the initial advantage of starting with the ball. From there, the playbook unfolds, a delicate blend of strategy, execution, and a touch of luck. Sudden Death was the old way of extending tied at the end of regulation NFL contests. The new NFL Overtime Rules is one way for the regular season and a bit different in the postseason.

Regular Season: How does NFL overtime work?

The revised regular-season overtime rule retains the 10 minutes but guarantees each team at least one possession unless the opening drive culminates in a touchdown. If the team that takes the ball first crosses the goal line, it is game over and that squad wins. No score or a field goal on the first offensive series in OT makes the game continue on. After that first mele of offense by each team, if the score is still tied the “sudden death” element returns.  

This seemingly minor tweak carries significant implications. Proponents hail it as a win for fairness, ensuring both teams have a chance regardless of a coin toss. Detractors, however, argue that no matter what even in the case of the fist team garnering a TD, their opponent should have the opportunity to follow suit. Traditionalist sudden death supporters argue priorities of efficiency over suspense, potentially diminishing the heart-stopping tension of sudden-death finishes.

The safety argument also plays a prominent role. Shorter games translate to less physical exertion, potentially reducing injury risk. However, critics point out that fatigue accumulates over time, particularly for defensive units exposed to repeated drives. Ultimately, the impact on player safety remains to be seen, necessitating further data and analysis.

Postseason: Parity of the NFL Playoff Overtime Rules

The postseason rules undergo a more dramatic transformation. Gone is the first touchdown win mantra of the regular season OT rules and, in its place, the guarantee of at least one possession for each team, regardless of initial scoring. This significant shift prioritizes fairness, ensuring both offenses have a chance to showcase their firepower.

But what about the drama? Will extended overtime dilute the electrifying tension of sudden death? Fans accustomed to nail-biting finishes might initially lament the change. However, the potential for extended back-and-forth battles could create its brand of excitement, showcasing offensive prowess and defensive resilience over multiple drives.

The Reasons for Change

The recent wave of revisions to the NFL Overtime Rules is a culmination of frustrated fans from recently played games. Sudden Death seemed like a cheap fix to an otherwise exciting back-and-forth slugfest, and it was a deflating sequence when a kicker of the team that won the OT coin flip and would win on the leg of their kicker without the other having a chance to answer the bell.

13 Seconds: Echoes of Heartbreak in the “Mahomes vs. Allen Epic

2021 AFC Divisional playoff game

---

---

The 2021 AFC Divisional playoff game of the Buffalo Bills visiting the Kansas City Chiefs is the main culprit of change, at least for the NFL Playoff Overtime Rules fixes.

The 2021 AFC Divisional Round matchup between the Buffalo Bills and Kansas City Chiefs wasn’t just a playoff game; it was an epic duel etched in football lore. A symphony of offensive fireworks, quarterback heroics, and a gut-wrenching finish, all condensed into 63 minutes that left fans breathless and some with hearts shattered. This thriller had four lead changes and 25 points scored in the final two minutes of the regularly allotted time. Yet, the final 13 seconds of the Fourth Quarter hold a special place in NFL history, forever branded as the “Mahomes vs. Allen Epic” and “13 Seconds” for the legendary narrative they weave.

Josh Allen, the Bills’ gunslinger, had carved his name on the scoreboard with four touchdown passes, defying gravity and logic with his athleticism. Patrick Mahomes, the Chiefs’ maestro, countered with laser throws and Houdini-esque escapes, orchestrating his own three-touchdown masterpiece. It was a back-and-forth ballet of offensive brilliance, leaving the Bills up on the score with a 36-33 lead as the clock held only thirteen ticks remaining.

Those 13 seconds seemed like a safe bet for Buffalo’s victory, but they have been a few seconds too many. A Chiefs drive fueled by Mahomes’ magic marched 44-yards to allow KC Kicker Harrison Butker to nail a 49-yard boot through the uprights to send the game into OT.

In the extra session, the home team Chiefs, won the coin toss and marched down the field again, scoring a TD to end the battle without a single possession by the Bills in overtime.

Almost Repeated the Same Day

---

---

Just hours later, the NFC Divisional Playoff between the Champion Tampa Bay Bucs and the LA Rams almost went down similarly. Tom Brady and his Tampa mates erased a 27-3 Rams lead to tie the game with 42 seconds left. The Rams, on the arm of Matthew Stafford and the soft hands of Cooper Cupp, positioned themselves for a Rams game-winning FG as time expired. Had this game gone to overtime and a victory arose from the first possession of the extra session, it would have been an NFL fandom meltdown. 

Conclusion

So, while the NFL Overtime Rules have expanded and adapted to the sport’s progression, the change is dynamic and hopefully reviewed each year by the NFL Competition Committee to keep the game as exciting of a fair and level playing field for both teams as possible. Let’s hope we get to enjoy more OT in the future, as it extends the game we love, and also hope that it provides equal footing and opportunity for the participants.

---

---

Join our Sports Reference Community

Of Statheads:

Subscribe to Stathead, the most powerful research tools in sports, and find any player, team, season, game, and any play. With over 80 different search tools for baseball, basketball, football, and hockey, you’ve got infinite answers at your finger tips.

With Our Email Newsletters:

Sign up for our newsletter and get curated stats, recaps, and more from the Pro Football Reference to your inbox every morning. No commitment, unsubscribe at any time.

On Social Media:

Stay connected with Pro Football Reference on social media! Bringing you stats, trivia, and more on all our channels daily.

Twitter – Instagram – Facebook – TikTok – YouTube – Reddit – LinkedIn

Follow the rest of the Sports Reference sites on social here.

Introduction

It is an age-old water cooler conversation between sports fans on who the best NFL defense of all time is. There are differing opinions on what determines what great defense is and who the title belongs to. This article lists the best defenses of All Time in NFL history and some of the reasons and players that give them that status.

Read the rest of this entry