Pro Football Reference Blog

10 Best Quarterbacks in the NFL

Posted by Darin Hayes on September 19, 2023

Introduction

The quarterback is the singular position on a football team that can make or break the organization’s success during a game or even a season. The National Football League is no exception to this rule, and in this post, we will cover the NFL’s Best Quarterbacks of all time.

How is the best QB of All-Time determined? Great question; we will use some of the information of stats and figures powered by the Pro-Football-Reference.com database and Stathead.com to find the best signal callers in NFL history of:

-Completion Percentage

-Passing Yards

-Best Turnover Ratio

-Touchdown Throws

-Championships

So, let’s review the information and judge the top 10 quarterbacks of all time.

NFL QBs with the Highest Completions Percentages

Connecting with teammates on passes is an important task of the signal caller. It is not just held in high regard, but it is the expectation of the coaches, executives, players, and fans that the quarterback finds an open receiver and hits in the hands with a spiral every time they drop back. That expectation is unachievable, but the player who completes the most has his team set up to win.

Here are the QBs that have connected with receivers better than everyone else.


Photo of Joe Burrow

Joe Burrow

Joseph Lee Burrow  (Joe Brrr, Joe Shiesty or Joey Franchise)

Position: QB Throws: Right

6-4221lb (193cm, 100kg)

Team: Cincinnati Bengals

Born: December 10, 1996 in Ames, IA (Age: 26-281d)

College: Ohio St., LSU  (College Stats)

Weighted Career AV (100-95-…): 38 (2756th overall since 1960)

High School: Athens (OH)

Draft: Cincinnati Bengals in the 1st round (1st overall) of the 2020 NFL Draft.

Twitter: @JoeyB  · Instagram: joeyb_9

SUMMARY

2023

Career

G

1

43

AV

39

QBrec

0-1-0

24-18-1

Cmp%

45.2

67.8

Yds

82

11856

Y/A

2.6

7.6

TD

0

82

Int

0

31

FantPt

3.2

841.8

This young gun of the Cincinnati Bengals picked up in the pros what he was doing back as a Tiger at LSU, putting passes on the hands of his targeted pass catchers. In the 2023 season, Joe Burrow has already started over 40 games and is at the top of the completion percentage in NFL history. His lofty just-over 68% completion number has the fans, coaches, and eligible receivers on the Bengals happy on Sunday afternoons and is a big reason the Bengals have gone deep into the playoffs each season Burrow has been healthy.


Photo of Jimmy Garoppolo

Jimmy Garoppolo

James Garoppolo  (Jimmy GQ, Prince Aladdin or Great Garoppolo)

Position: QB Throws: Right

6-2225lb (188cm, 102kg)

Team: Las Vegas Raiders

Born: November 2, 1991 in Arlington Heights, IL (Age: 31-319d)

College: East. Illinois

Weighted Career AV (100-95-…): 46 (1998th overall since 1960)

High School: Rolling Meadows (IL)

Draft: New England Patriots in the 2nd round (62nd overall) of the 2014 NFL Draft.

Pronunciation: \guh-ROP-uh-loh\

Twitter: @JimmyG_10  · Instagram: jimmypolo10

SUMMARY

2023

Career

G

1

75

AV

50

QBrec

1-0-0

41-17-0

Cmp%

76.9

67.8

Yds

200

14489

Y/A

7.7

8.3

TD

2

89

Int

1

43

FantPt

15.1

900.8

Jimmy G. is neck-and-neck with Burrow in pass completion percentage. This former New England Patriot and San Francisco 49er QB is now a Los Vegas Raider and ready to add to what he has done: hit receivers with catchable passes downfield. Garoppolo is also on the verge of completing 68% of his passes thrown for his career and is mere percentage points behind Joe B. of the Bengals but with many more passes and games under his belt.

Leaders in Passing Yards

If we choose to see who has advanced the ball through the air the most in NFL history, we have a great list of legendary huddle bosses to talk about. Let us look first at who has the most productive yardage per game.


Photo of Patrick Mahomes

Patrick Mahomes

Patrick Lavon Mahomes II  (Grim Reaper, Showtime, Magic Man, The Musician, Fatrick, The Gunslinger or Mahomeboy)

Position: QB Throws: Right

6-2225lb (188cm, 102kg)

Team: Kansas City Chiefs

Born: September 17, 1995 in Tyler, TX (Age: 28-000d, Happy Birthday!)

College: Texas Tech  (College Stats)

Weighted Career AV (100-95-…): 85 (334th overall since 1960)

High School: Whitehouse (TX)

Draft: Kansas City Chiefs in the 1st round (10th overall) of the 2017 NFL Draft.

Instagram: patrickmahomes

SUMMARY

2023

Career

G

1

81

AV

94

QBrec

0-1-0

64-17-0

Cmp%

53.8

66.2

Yds

226

24467

Y/A

5.8

8.1

TD

2

194

Int

1

50

FantPt

19.5

1886.5

Unsurprisingly, the reigning Super Bowl MVP would be at the top of passing yards per game average. The young Kansas City Chiefs star, going into the 2023 season, manages to float the pigskin downfield for an amazing 303 yards average in each game he starts. No wonder this guy wins ball games! That is not to say his teammates and coaches haven’t helped him get to this point, but still, to be able to chuck the rock that much each game makes one’s arm sore just thinking about it.


Another current AFC West quarterback still on the upside of his career plays in the City of Angels wearing a lightning bolt on the sides of his helmet. Justin Herbert and his teammates produce 287 yards of passing offense per game in games this young man from the Oregon Ducks program starts for LA.

Photo of Justin Herbert

Justin Herbert

Justin Patrick Herbert

Position: QB Throws: Right

6-6237lb (198cm, 107kg)

Team: Los Angeles Chargers

Born: March 10, 1998 in Eugene, OR (Age: 25-191d)

College: Oregon  (College Stats)

Weighted Career AV (100-95-…): 43 (2253rd overall since 1960)

High School: Sheldon (OR)

Draft: Los Angeles Chargers in the 1st round (6th overall) of the 2020 NFL Draft.

Instagram: justinherbert

SUMMARY

2023

Career

G

1

50

AV

45

QBrec

0-1-0

25-25-0

Cmp%

69.7

67.0

Yds

229

14318

Y/A

6.9

7.2

TD

1

95

Int

0

35

FantPt

20.9

1013.8


Being a good quarterback means keeping possession of the football by not allowing big mistakes, like throwing an interception. So far in his career, one man has taken better care of the ball than anyone else.

Taking care of the Football


Photo of Aaron Rodgers

Aaron Rodgers

Aaron Charles Rodgers  (A-Rod)

Position: QB Throws: Right

6-2225lb (188cm, 102kg)

Team: New York Jets (Injured Reserve)

Born: December 2, 1983 in Chico, CA (Age: 39-289d)

College: Butte JC (CA), California  (College Stats)

Weighted Career AV (100-95-…): 163 (4th overall since 1960)

High School: Pleasant Valley (CA)

Draft: Green Bay Packers in the 1st round (24th overall) of the 2005 NFL Draft.

Twitter: @AaronRodgers12  · Instagram: aaronrodgers12

SUMMARY

2023

Career

G

1

231

AV

231

QBrec

1-0-0

148-75-1

Cmp%

0.0

65.3

Yds

0

59055

Y/A

0.0

7.7

TD

0

475

Int

0

105

FantPt

4569.6

Career  NFL Touchdown Throws

Putting points on the board is another expected function of the team quarterback. The following gentlemen under center and shotgun formation have done that more times than everyone else.


Photo of Peyton Manning

Peyton Manning

Peyton Williams Manning  (The Sheriff, The Caveman or Peydirt)

Position: QB Throws: Right

6-5230lb (196cm, 104kg)

Born: March 24, 1976 in New Orleans, LA (Age: 47-177d)

College: Tennessee  (College Stats)

Weighted Career AV (100-95-…): 176 (2nd overall since 1960)

High School: Isidore Newman (LA)

Draft: Indianapolis Colts in the 1st round (1st overall) of the 1998 NFL Draft.

Hall of Fame: Inducted as Player in 2021 (Full List)

Relatives: Brother Eli Manning; Father Archie Manning

SUMMARY

Career

G

266

AV

271

QBrec

186-79-0

Cmp%

65.3

Yds

71940

Y/A

7.7

TD

539

Int

251

FantPt

4686.3

The man who called out “Omaha” more than Nebraska’s Governor was one of the best at reading a defense, changing protections, and sometimes the play at the line. Manning learned from one of the best, his father, Archie Manning, the patriarch of the first family of quarterbacks. Peyton threw for 539 TDs and almost 72,000 yards as he won Super Bowls with two franchises, the Indianapolis Colts and the Denver Broncos.


Photo of Drew Brees

Drew Brees

Drew Christopher Brees

Position: QB Throws: Right

6-0209lb (183cm, 94kg)

Born: January 15, 1979 in Austin, TX (Age: 44-245d)

College: Purdue  (College Stats)

Weighted Career AV (100-95-…): 167 (3rd overall since 1960)

High School: Westlake (TX)

Draft: San Diego Chargers in the 2nd round (32nd overall) of the 2001 NFL Draft.

Twitter: @drewbrees  · Instagram: drewbrees

SUMMARY

Career

G

287

AV

277

QBrec

172-114-0

Cmp%

67.7

Yds

80358

Y/A

7.6

TD

571

Int

243

FantPt

5185.0

Meanwhile, down in the Bayou… Drew Brees racked up quite the career numbers after going to New Orleans after an early stint in sunny San Diego. Brees was not only the Super Bowl XLIV MVP, but the former Purdue QB also tossed 571 TDs and passed for over 80,000 yards! Brees might have been small compared to many of his peers, but he stands tall as one of the best to play the position ever.


Photo of Tom Brady

Tom Brady

Thomas Edward Patrick Brady  (TB12, Tom Terrific, Touchdown Tom, GOAT, The Pharaoh, Comeback Kid or Sir)

Position: QB Throws: Right

6-4225lb (193cm, 102kg)

Born: August 3, 1977 in San Mateo, CA (Age: 46-045d)

College: Michigan  (College Stats)

Weighted Career AV (100-95-…): 184 (1st overall since 1960)

High School: Junipero Serra (CA)

Draft: New England Patriots in the 6th round (199th overall) of the 2000 NFL Draft.

Instagram: tombrady

SUMMARY

Career

G

335

AV

326

QBrec

251-82-0

Cmp%

64.3

Yds

89214

Y/A

7.4

TD

649

Int

212

FantPt

5943.4

We couldn’t dance our way around this name anymore. Tom Brady is at the top of many categories that we like to look at for metrics of a QB. The most wins, TDs, Championships, passing yards, years played, games started, and a partridge in a pear tree all belong to this longtime New England Patriots and Tampa Bay Buccaneers field boss. There are probably a dozen more categories he leads in, too. It is still amazing that 198 players were taken before him in the 2000 NFL Draft.


Game-Winning Drives and 4th Quarter Comebacks

Who do you want in the huddle when the game is online at the end of a half? We know that Peyton Manning and Tom Brady are at the top of the list for game-winning drives and late-game rallies. Still, a couple of other signal callers were comparable in this category, playing fewer games than the two leaders in the clubhouse at comebacks.


Photo of Ben Roethlisberger

Ben Roethlisberger

Benjamin Todd Roethlisberger  (Big Ben)

Position: QB Throws: Right

6-5240lb (196cm, 108kg)

Born: March 2, 1982 in Lima, OH (Age: 41-199d)

College: Miami (OH)  (College Stats)

Weighted Career AV (100-95-…): 131 (25th overall since 1960)

High School: Findlay (OH)

Draft: Pittsburgh Steelers in the 1st round (11th overall) of the 2004 NFL Draft.

Pronunciation: \RAWTH-lihs-bur-gur\

SUMMARY

Career

G

249

AV

208

QBrec

165-81-1

Cmp%

64.4

Yds

64088

Y/A

7.6

TD

418

Int

211

FantPt

4019.5

Big Ben led the Pittsburgh Steelers to 53 game-winning drives and 41 final-quarter comebacks. He led Pittsburgh for almost two decades, appearing in three Super Bowls and taking home two Lombardi Trophies. Roethlisberger also holds the record for the most 500-yard passing games by a quarterback, racing the milestone three times.


Another Captain Comeback to consider has a City of Pittsburgh connection.

Dan Marino

Daniel Constantine Marino Jr.

Position: QB Throws: Right

6-4224lb (193cm, 101kg)

Born: September 15, 1961 in Pittsburgh, PA (Age: 62-002d)

College: Pittsburgh  (College Stats)

Weighted Career AV (100-95-…): 145 (14th overall since 1960)

High School: Central Catholic (PA)

Draft: Miami Dolphins in the 1st round (27th overall) of the 1983 NFL Draft.

Hall of Fame: Inducted as Player in 2005 (Full List)

Pronunciation: \ma-REE-no\

Twitter: @DanMarino  · Instagram: dan13marino

SUMMARY

Career

G

242

AV

216

QBrec

147-93-0

Cmp%

59.4

Yds

61361

Y/A

7.3

TD

420

Int

252

FantPt

3594.5

Marino grew up in the Steel City and played on the Pitt Panthers football team, which earned him to be picked by the Miami Dolphins in the 1st round of the 1983 NFL Draft. Dan the Man produced 47 Game Winning Drives during his 17-year NFL career, with 33 comebacks in the game’s waning moments.


In Conclusion

The quarterback throwing the ball has been all that more important in the modern NFL game, and you can see why the men mentioned above have been so important to the success of their respective teams. So, whatever the criteria for determining the greatest quarterback of all time, you can pick your poison with these stalwarts!

Comments are closed.